We Have Issues offers audio versions of articles using Instaread. Some words may be mispronounced.
Halls Of Stone is a darker and more lore heavy episode that serves the larger story exceptionally well. It concentrates on the consequences of power rather than rushing towards spectacle, and in doing so it delivers some of the series’ most compelling character work to date. The episode moves between the underground kingdom of Khazad dûm, the workshops of Eregion and the increasingly fractured society of Númenor, weaving these strands together with a quiet confidence that has not always been present earlier in the run.
In Khazad dûm the episode opens with King Durin III taking possession of one of the seven rings forged for the dwarf lords. The ring grants him an almost supernatural understanding of the mountain. Where they have struggled for months to restore the light shafts that once fed their crops, the king is able to sense precisely where to strike. He takes up an axe himself and opens a foundation wall, flooding the lower halls with sunlight for the first time in an age. The moment is both triumphant and unsettling. The ring whispers to him as he works, and the camera lingers on his face long enough for you to register the shift taking place. What begins as practical salvation quickly becomes ambition. Restrictions on mining depth are abolished. The king summons representatives from the other dwarf realms and offers them the remaining rings, but only in exchange for half of their future profits. Greed has settled in.
Prince Durin watches his father change and grows alarmed. Disa, meanwhile, chases a small crystal intended as a birthday gift for their child into a forgotten lower chamber. There she uses her stonesinging and hears, in return, a deep and ancient roar rising from far below. Something nameless and terrible stirs in the depths. She and her husband take the warning to the king, yet Durin III, now fully under the ring’s influence, dismisses their concerns and orders the diggers to go deeper still. In a calculated gesture of reconciliation he restores his son’s title as heir. The prince is momentarily won over, though Disa extracts a private promise that he will never himself wear one of the rings. It’s handled with restraint and atmosphere. The halls feel vast and lived in, the lighting shifts from warm gold to cold shadow as the tone darkens, and the performances, particularly from Peter Mullan and Sophia Nomvete, carry genuine weight.
Meanwhile, Celebrimbor and the dwarf Narvi unveil the great western gate they have crafted together, the Doors of Durin. The ceremony is brief but effective, a public affirmation of the renewed friendship between elves and dwarves. Yet the forge in Eregion is already turning towards darker work. Annatar, still presenting himself as a benevolent guide from the Valar, presses Celebrimbor to begin forging rings for the race of Men. Celebrimbor resists. Men, he argues, are too easily corrupted; any gift of power would create more problems than it solved. Annatar appears to accept the refusal and begins the work alone.
One of Celebrimbor’s young smiths, Mirdania, tests an unfinished ring and vanishes into the Unseen World. When she returns she is shaken. She describes a tall figure whose skin seemed made of flame, whose eyes were hideous and eternal, and who reeked of death. Annatar is quick to soothe her, suggesting the vision was merely a reflection of Celebrimbor’s own exhausted spirit. The exchange is chilling precisely because of its politeness. Charlie Vickers continues to play Annatar with an almost courtly restraint that makes every smile feel slightly wrong. Charles Edwards is equally good as Celebrimbor, the great craftsman whose pride and guilt are slowly being turned against him.
Prince Durin arrives in Eregion and voices his suspicions about the rings and about Annatar himself. Celebrimbor confronts his collaborator and demands to know whether the seven rings were altered in any way. Annatar’s reply is pure manipulation. He points out that Celebrimbor lied to High King Gil galad about closing the forge, and that this deception entered the process. The impurity, he suggests, is therefore Celebrimbor’s own. There are only two paths forward: confess everything to the High King and risk the end of the entire project, or forge nine new rings for Men of such perfect quality that they might redeem the seven. Celebrimbor, unable to face the first option, chooses the second. The decision is presented without melodrama, simply as the logical outcome of a man who cannot bear to see his life’s work judged a failure.
In Númenor the political situation hardens into open repression. Pharazôn consolidates his rule. His son Kemen, together with Elendil’s daughter Eärien, strips the Sea Guard of rank if they remain loyal to the former queen. A memorial gathering at an ancient shrine becomes the flashpoint. Kemen arrives with orders to clear the site for a new aqueduct. When he deliberately destroys a sacred relic, a brawl erupts. Valandil gains the upper hand and has Kemen at sword point, but Elendil orders him to stand down. Valandil obeys. Kemen then picks up the fallen blade and stabs him in the back. Elendil is arrested and blamed for leading an uprising. It is brutal and abrupt, does not linger on the violence, yet the shock of Valandil’s death is impactful. The island that once seemed a place of measured debate is now shown to be sliding towards tyranny and civil conflict.
Towards the episode Elrond reaches Lindon and warns Gil galad that Adar’s orc army is marching on Eregion. The High King, already troubled by visions granted by his own ring, believes Sauron is the true architect of the coming war. He hesitates to commit his forces fully, fearing he cannot fight both Adar and Sauron at once. The decision leaves Celebrimbor and his city exposed.
The episode succeed more than the earlier dialogue driven chapters because it allows the conversations carry the weight of the story and drive it forward. The dialogue between Celebrimbor and Annatar is sharp and layered. The quiet moments in Khazad dûm, the brief exchanges between father and son, the sudden violence in Númenor, all feel connected by the same underlying theme: the cost of accepting power that promises more than it can safely deliver.
By the final scenes the seven rings are already working their influence, the nine are about to be forged, and the free peoples of Middle earth remain largely unaware of how thoroughly the ground has shifted beneath them. Halls Of Stone is a confident, atmospheric, and uses the power of suggestion and the slow burn of moral compromise. It is one of the strongest episodes of the series so far, grounded in character, rich in detail, and quietly ominous about what is still to come.
Where to watch The Lord Of The Rings: The Rings Of Power – Season 2, Episode 5: Halls Of Stone: