Three episodes in and this spin-off is chugging along with some stylish animation and fun action but some frustrating shortcuts are preventing it from fully clicking. Picking up in the thick of a harsh 1985 Hawkins winter, the story follows the gang as they tangle with the eerie, adapting plant-like entities that first showed up in the pumpkin patch and Winter Festival chaos. This time around, the focus shifts toward understanding what these new monsters are as everyone believes the connection to the upside down has been shut off.
The episode picks up directly from where we left of with Dustin’s nemesis, Rosa, possessed by a massive half plant, half demogorgon vine monster. An effective action scene showcases the gang’s – Mike, Dustin, Lucas, Will, Max, Eleven and new friend Nikki – individual skills and how the work together to succeed. However, there is one thing that is becoming obvious, the show haas very quickly become over reliant on El as a get out of jail free card.
After the showdown in the woods, the group decide that, rather than tell an adult, they need to investigate what is going on themselves. Fortunately, Nikki’s mother is the school’s new substitute science teacher Mrs. Baxter. Voiced by Janeane Garofalo with just the right amount of eccentric enthusiasm, Baxter lectures on rapid adaptation and survival pressures in a way that mirrors the spore-spewing threats the kids have been dodging. It’s a move that lets the young cast bounce ideas off each other while giving you a crash course in how these mutants might be one step ahead. The teams investigations has them following clues in the snow-covered woods and eventually toward an abandoned sawmill on the outskirts of town. What begins as a fact-finding mission quickly turns into a high-stakes fight with two more plant creatures that demonstrate new abilities: they can now still function when the human host is removed.
Character work remains one of the episode’s brighter spots, even if it doesn’t dig as deep as it could. The core friendships are intact – Mike’s protective instincts flare up when Eleven puts herself in harm’s way, and Will’s quiet sensitivity to the otherworldly vibes gets a couple of subtle nods. Max and Lucas share some quick, lighthearted moments to grow their relationship. Eleven’s powers get a fun showcase even though they are becoming the series’ crutch. Mrs. Baxter’s addition is a nice touch, adding an adult to the series that isn’t drenched in grief or sinister.
Pacing is brisk, the episode flies by and doesn’t leave you the opportunity to become bored. The story moves set piece to exposition to set piecef without dragging, and the clues build logically toward bigger revelations about how these entities might be linked to leftover Upside Down energy or perhaps even human interference. The threat feels larger and more insidious, with the spores suggesting a spreading infection that could change Hawkins in permanent ways. That said, the condensed format also means some subplots get shortchanged. Adult characters from the original series are AWOL, and the emotional weight of what these kids are facing is sacrificed for forward momentum. It teases fascinating ideas about evolution and survival but pulls back just as things start to feel truly profound.
The episode respects the source material by keeping the spotlight on the younger characters and their camaraderie while planting seeds for what could become a town-wide crisis but tonally a lot of the show feels off. There is a clear intention to pull in younger viewers – but would you watch this if you haven’t seen the live-action show? There are references to Alien and Friday The 13th but the animation tones down any horrors. The creatures are conceptually cool with their rapid mutations and spore mechanics, but they lack the visceral presence of Demogorgons or Mind Flayer tendrils. There’s also a reliance on established Stranger Things shorthand, which may confuse any new viewers, instead of taking bigger creative swings.
It all entertains while you’re watching it but it all feels unnecessary and won’t become part of any Stranger Things re-watches.
🌟🌟🌟
We Have Issues 