

We Have Issues offers audio versions of articles using Instaread. Some words may be mispronounced.
The fifth episode of The Rings of Power’s third season hits the brakes after the intensity of the fourth. Set five years on from the fall of Eregion, it spreads its attention across several corners of Middle earth and beyond, following characters who are still recovering from recent losses while trying to position themselves against Sauron’s growing reach. The result is an episode that offers strong character work and a handful of memorable set pieces, yet one that also struggles to maintain momentum once the initial tension begins to dissipate.

The episode opens in the aftermath of the chaos at Gundabad. Marnûkh, the orc who has become an unexpected ally to the heros, finds himself a prisoner of Sauron. Strapped down and subjected to psychological pressure rather than simple physical force, he is forced to confront the reality of his children’s fate. Sauron’s methods prove effective. The orc breaks and reveals that Galadriel and Celeborn are heading toward the borders of Eryn Galen, the great forest that will one day darken into Mirkwood. The sceneis effective in its cruelty. Charlie Vickers continues to play Sauron with a quiet, almost conversational menace that makes the threats land harder than any raised voice could. Leaving Marnûkh alive to suffer with the knowledge that his children were already dead is consistent with the Sauron’s non-theatrical malice.
Meanwhile Galadriel and Celeborn, having escaped Gundabad with the aid of a Great Eagle, part ways with their aerial rescuer and attempt to move on foot through the forest. Their conversations while hiding in the trees provide some of the episode’s more intimate moments. Celeborn recounts how he survived the destruction of his forces by Ancalagon in the First Age, only to be captured and moved between prisons for centuries. Galadriel apologises for her long obsession with hunting Sauron, admitting she had believed her husband dead. The exchange carries genuine weight after their long separation, though the decision to abandon the eagle for the sake of this quieter drama remains somewhat baffling. When Galadriel, still haunted by visions of Sauron, falls from their hiding place and alerts nearby orcs, Celeborn surrenders himself to draw them away. Sauron arrives soon after, recognising the elf lord from ancient battles and taking him as both bait and potential source of information.

Back with the Elves, Elrond and High King Gil-Galad travel to Númenor seeking an alliance against the combined threats of Mordor and Rhûn. A flashback to the First Age shows Elrond and his twin brother Elros at the moment of a crossroads. Elros elects mortality and the kingship of the new island realm of men, while Elrond remains among the elves. Robert Aramayo plays both brothers with a quiet sadness. In the present day the reception in Númenor is far cooler. Ar Pharazôn receives the elves with outward courtesy but his court treats them with a mixture of curiosity and barely concealed superiority. Belzagar’s fascination with Elrond’s resemblance to the long dead Elros underlines how the kingdom has drifted from its founding ideals. Pharazôn makes clear that any military support will depend on the resolution of Númenor’s own internal conflict with the Faithful led by Míriel and Elendil. Elrond encounters Isildur and is eventually brought before Míriel, only to discover that Elendil’s forces are already assembling for what appears to be open battle. The political manoeuvring is clearly outlined, even if the conversations sometimes stretch longer than necessary.
In Rhûn the story turns to Gandalf’s confrontation with Pallando. The former Blue Wizard has aligned himself with darker forces and now sits in a position of power, with the Ring servant Khamûl close at hand. Gandalf attempts to appeal to their shared origins as servants of the Secret Fire, hoping to turn Pallando back toward the light. The conversation is tense and philosophical, but it does not remain talk for long. A wizard battle does arrive, complete with the expected displays of power and physical struggle. Gandalf is ultimately overmatched. He wakes later to find himself bound to the back of an oliphaunt as the vast armies of Rhûn begin their march toward Mordor. The scene delivers the spectacle many will have been waiting for, but by this point the pacing has hit a brick wall.

After the energy of the duel and the earlier tension surrounding Galadriel and Celeborn’s flight, the narrative slows considerably. Characters spend extended periods waiting, talking, or moving between locations without advancing the larger conflict in any decisive way. The Númenórean court scenes, while full of political subtext, begin to feel monotonus. Galadriel’s remaining time in the forest after Celeborn’s capture loses urgency. Even Sauron’s interrogation of his new prisoner, though unsettling, occupies more screen time than it strictly needs. The episode becomes a series of holding patterns rather than building to something. This is the definition of a show treading water. This is not to say the material is poorly written. The dialogue often carries emotional honesty, particularly in the exchanges between Elrond and Isildur about loss and legacy, or between Galadriel and Celeborn as they try to bridge centuries of absence. The problem is that these quieter beats are allowed to dominate for too long after the more kinetic scenes have already done their work.
Production values remain consistently high. The forests of Eryn Galen look dense and ancient. The halls of Númenor retain their sense of faded grandeur mixed with growing arrogance. The forces of Rhûn are given a scale that makes their eventual arrival in the west feel genuinely threatening. The performances are solid across the board. Morfydd Clark continues to convey Galadriel’s internal conflict without tipping into melodrama. Jamie Campbell Bower brings a grounded weariness to Celeborn that helps sell the character’s long captivity. Daniel Weyman and Ciarán Hinds make the wizard confrontation feel like a genuine clash of equals rather than a simple power fantasy. Trystan Gravelle’s Pharazôn remains a compelling figure of ambition and insecurity.
What holds the episode back is its reluctance to keep the various threads moving at a consistent pace. Having delivered a satisfying wizard battle and some strong character moments, it then settles into a pattern of preparation and conversation that dilutes the earlier tension. The episode does important work in setting up the conflicts still to come, particularly the precarious situation in Númenor and Sauron’s continued search for the knowledge needed to complete the One Ring. Yet it does so at a cost to the sense of urgency that the season had established so effectively in its opening hours.

By the end, several key pieces have been moved into place. Celeborn is in Sauron’s hands. The armies of Rhûn are on the march with Gandalf as an unwilling passenger. Númenor teeters on the edge of civil war even as the elves seek its aid. These developments matter, and they are presented with care. The episode simply takes too long in places to reach them, allowing the momentum built elsewhere to dissipate. It is a solid middle chapter that deepens several relationships and delivers the magical confrontation many anticipated, but one that struggles to maintain the same level of engagement once the more dramatic sequences have passed. The season still has time to regain its stride, yet this particular chapter serves as a reminder that even in a story of this scale, pacing remains as important as spectacle.

Where to watch The Lord Of The Rings: The Rings Of Power – Season 3, Episode 5: The Lady Of Lórien:

