
We Have Issues offers audio versions of articles using Instaread. Some words may be mispronounced.
Ah yes, the humble prequel. Whenever a franchise finds it can no longer go forwards, but doesn’t want to lose its hard earned continuity to a reboot, going back to the start always proves to be the more enticing option. Star Wars took it, the X-Men took it and even the Transformers realised that retreat is the better part of valour. However, if one franchise seemed tailor-made to thump a rebellious fist on the button marked “prequel” it’s The Hunger Games.
When we last left the shifting fortunes of Panem, Katniss Everdeen had finally managed to purge the capital of not one, but two corrupting influences that managed to come at a high personal cost. Finally settling down with Peeta to raise children, it seems that we’d reached the end of the saga first featured within the young adult novels of Suzanne Collins – however, when your author has such a detailed world and varied characters as this one swirling round her mind palace, there’s always ways to draw out a series for another adventure. And if nothing else, at least it helps the franchise to scratch that itch of continuing to whip up some of the most ludicrous character names in cinema.

Sixty-four years before he became the softly spoken, tyrannical president of Panem, we find a young Coriolanus Snow trying to hide the financial troubles of his family while striving to win the Plinth Prize scholarship to ensure his continuing education and aid his struggling fortunes. However, while his studious nature has all but guaranteed himself a victory, Dean Casca Highbottom pulls the rug out from under him by changing the rules to something utter unorthodox. It seems that despite only starting ten years ago, annual event known as the Hunger Games is already experiencing flagging ratings as two tributes from all the twelve districts all fight to the death to commemorate the failure of an earlier uprising.
Completely different to the flashy dog and pony show the Hunger Games eventually becomes, in this time period the tributes are treated as subhuman trash, fit only to die in the concrete confines of the arena – but in an effort to boost those ratings, Head Gamesmaster Dr. Volumnia Gaul has decided to make the students mentors to each tribute and grade them on their progress. While having their tributes ultimately win would be a boost to their scores, they’re mainly going to be marked on how well their subjects get over with the crowd and the final endgame is that if the people watching actually care about this year’s lambs to the slaughter, it’ll snag more viewers.
Snow is assigned feisty songbird Lucy Gray Bird from District 12, who immediately stands out from the crowd after belting out a defiant tune at her reaping and attacking the mayor’s daughter with a snake. But while his peers see Bird as nothing more than trouble, Snow sees spirited clay that can be molded into exactly what the Games need. However, as he negotiates the politics and the rules of his task, Snow finds himself drawn to his tribute the more he comes to understand her. But as we know Coriolanus Snow is destined to become the cold hearted totalitarian that holds Panem in the palm of his hand, chances of a happy ending seem slim.

The issues a franchise has when stepping into the realms of a prequel are well documented. Not only do you have to ensure that storylines separated by multiple decades glide and merge smoothly into one another, and overcome the fact that we already know the fate of the main character, it has to negotiate the issue of characters we’ve been following for the past four movies are now nowhere to be seen due to the rather understandable excuse that they haven’t been born yet. The thing is, whenever The Ballards Of Songbirds And Snakes sticks to those trusted and true conventions of the franchise, it fulfills the brief surprisingly well, but when it strays to tell a bigger story, this latest iteration of The Hunger Games goes on a little too long for comfort.
So let’s delve first into the pros and from purely a world building perspective, rewinding the clock to examine both the Capitol and the games themselves in their relative infancy is actually quite facinating. The retro-futurist pantomime of the Capitol gets even more retro and the expansive, high tech versions of the titular games are now far more primitive, primal sprints surrounded by concrete and stone rather than the scenic, leafy marathons that occur over sixty years later. You can tell that returning director Francis Lawrence (now on his fouth, consecutive games) is having the most fun reverse engineering a world he helped build into a period piece dystopia that’s still trying to find its feet a decade after crushing an uprising. However, while we’ve returned back to witnessing the Games themselves again after Mockingjay Parts 1 & 2 left them out for understandable reasons, it wouldn’t truly be a Hunger Games flick if some doomed, yearning romance wasn’t gumming up the works.

With a lack of beloved characters such as Katniss, Peeta or even Haymitch to carry the load, The Ballard Of Songbirds And Snakes instead goes full Anakin Skywalker and gives us the origins of President Snow as he begins his climb to power from humble beginnings as a financially struggling student. Tom Blyth inhabits the role Donald Sutherland made infamous by gradually building that cold resolve as he learns to manipulate and plot his way to getting what he wants; but while Rachel Zegler’s Grey proves to be the wrong kind of distracting with numerous songs (the word Ballard is in the title for a reason) and a pseudo-Creole accent worthy of Channing Tatum’s Gambit to wrestle with, the typically respected supporting cast fills the gaps. Peter Dinklage looks like he’s carrying the weight of the world on his shoulders as the tormented Dean, Hunter Schafer helps give Snow depth as his kind cousin, Tigris, and Jason Schwartzman more than makes up for the precious lack of Stanley Tucci in the past two films by eating up the set as a similarly showbizzy ancestor of the Flickerman lineage. However, of all the supporting cast, none are committed to going all in and all out as Viola Davis who seems to be playing the deranged Head Gamesmaster while channeling Clarence Williams III from Tales From The Hood and stealing whole scenes for her efforts.
However, while Lawrence manages to use the period change to his advantage and deliver yet another variation of familiar franchise beats to deliver harsh political statements, once all the business concerning the games themselves pass, the film unfortunately flounders a little in its final hour. Shifting the dystopian paranoia from the Capitol to District 12 as a disgraced Snow attempts to both woo Lucy while smoking out a budding resistance simply slows matters down to a crawl and it certainly doesn’t help that we already know that the union between them is pre-ordained to crash and burn. It still ticks all those political boxes the YA series has made its own, but at least the film doesn’t try an snap it’s own spine while bending over backwards into making Snow into one of those tragic villain origin stories. Oh sure, he’s humanised, but even endless singing from Zegler can’t stop him from becoming the machiavellian bastard he was always destined to be.

For the most part, The Ballard Of Songbirds And Snakes does well to expand upon the history of its franchise while delivering a villain origin that fits snugly in with what we already knew. However, while the misadventures of Panem have never been more epic, a tighter story might have helped Snow to settle a little better.
🌟🌟🌟

