Tales From The Crypt – Season 6, Episode 3: Whirlpool (1994) – Review

Vintage horror comic book cover titled “Tales from the Crypt,” featuring a frightened woman in a green suit reaching upward against a purple supernatural background.

We Have Issues offers audio versions of articles using Instaread. Some words may be mispronounced.

Oh well, two out of three ain’t bad I suppose.
While the triple -serving of episodes that kick off a season of Tales From The Crypt gives us three chances to start things off strong, there’s always a danger of some outings being noticably better than the others. However, in the case of the final installment of season six’s premier trilogy, it almost seems unfair to compare this third episode to the previous two.
To kick things off, Highlander’s Russell Mulcahy continued to prove why he’s emerged as a series MVP with the stupendous “Let The Punishment Fit The Crime” and coming a close second was William Malone’s “Only Skin Deep”, which dealt out a harsher, steamier tone to deliver a rousing one-two punch to show that the Crypt Keeper hasn’t lost his touch. However, trailing in a distant third is “Whirlpool”, further proof that the show should think seriously about ditching those campy, comedic noir episodes for good.

Dark candlelit workshop with skulls, a severed head, paint cans, and eerie laboratory equipment

Rolanda is an artist for the Tales From The Crypt comic who is finding it hard to deliver quality work since she’s given up drinking. Her latest strip – a tale of revenge from beyond the grave with a twist – draws the ire of her boss, Vern, who flatly declares it shit and calls Rolanda into his office to fire her and put the additional boot in while suggesting that she was a better artist when she was a drunk. Jobless, Rolanda goes home to feel sorry for herself, but eventually returns to the office to give Vern a piece of her mind. Alongside that, she also ends up giving him a few bullets as well; but despite getting her violent revenge, her satisfaction is short lived when a cadre of cops meet her in the lobby and fill her full of lead.
The end, right? Well, no actually, as Rolanda wakes up at the begining of the day to discover that she’s got to live the whole, humiliating experience again. Yep, we’re in a classic Groundhog Day situation and as the time-displaced artist approaches the time of her firing once more, she decides to handle it in a slightly different way. Rather than storming back into the office after hours to blow Vern away, Rolanda instead chooses to drop her dignity rather than her boss and begs for her job back. However, this time, the incredibly paranoid Vern, convinced that his former employee has come to get revenge, pulls a gun on her and shoots her dead.
Waking once again at the beginning of the day, Rolanda tries something completely different for her third go around and decides to not go into work at all; but whatever paradoxical snare has her in its grasp, it isn’t about to let go, and again a paranoid run-in with a house calling Vern ends with both of them full of holes yet again. However, the universe has one more cosmic joke to play and when Rolanda and Vern once again get on the eternal merry-go-round, we find there’s been a bit of a role reversal.

Low-angle view of four people gathered around a seated man indoors, with a hanging light and drinks visible.

“Whirlpool” proves to be immensely frustrating for a number of reasons, but the main one is that the director of this episode is something of a major get. While I’d never class Mick Garris as an elite horror filmmaker per say, he does has a recognisable filmography (Critters 2, Sleepwalkers, the 1994 punt at The Stand) and is something of a reliable figure within the horror filmmaking communities of the 80s and 90s. However, while I’ll give Garris props for cooking up the Masters Of Horror anthology series back in 2005, his sole Tales From The Crypt entry leaves a hell of a lot to be desired. For a start, it’s one of those kooky, zany, comedy episodes that I’m rapidly starting to dislike; but like most other installments of its ilk, it proves to be painfully unfunny and the exaggerated humour and performances tend to be more annoying than anything else.
The cast is noticably strange too, with the main two roles of the unfortunate Rolanda and the fire-happy Vern going to the pairing of longtime friends, and stand-up comedians Rita Rudner and Richard Lewis. Yes, the two have easy chemistry, and watching Lewis in particular play an editor who seems weirdly happy to shoot his employee at the drop of a hat is kinda fun. However, the plot is so deliberately silly, anything approaching character logic flies out the window like a depressed stockbroker during the 1920s. No one behaves even remotely like a normal human being and virtually every decision made makes no sense whatsoever other than ensuring the leads die in hails of bullets. I get that the main aim of “Whirlpool” is to be one of those goofy, satirical, meta episodes (according to numerous episodes, working in the bullpen at Tales From The Crypt seemingly required sizeable health insurance), but if your epidode isn’t funny and isn’t not clever, what’s the point of it?

Man wearing a white shirt, black vest, and colorful tie in a dimly lit room

Even the Groundhog Day plot leaves plenty to be desired. Setting up such a thing is a tricky process that requires scripting tighter than a duck’s butthole, and you definitely need ample narrative room to manuver when it comes to the time it takes to explain it. However, at a remarkably short 20 minutes (including Crypt Keeper intros), Rolanda doesn’t even start her second go-round until we’re halfway through the episode. From here, we’re supposed to believe that all involved are driven to manic distraction despite only restarting twice, and even then, the rules suddenly change for a twist ending that not only doesn’t make any sense (everyone suddenly switches roles because… reasons), but it makes you glad that you don’t have to start the day again and watch this lackluster episode more than once. OK, so Mick Garris is hardly the measure of some of his peers when behind the camera, but Sleepwalkers is crazy fun and his Critters sequel is surprisingly slick – so you’d think he’d turn in a story with a bit more oomph.
By now, Tales From The Crypt must be starting to run a little dry on the stories featured within the pages of multiple EC Comics publications, buy I’d still wish they’d go lighter on the more humour/thriller based episodes and focus on the more original, manical ones. While I’ll grant you they probably save the producers money as they skimp on complicated effects work and must be quick to film, but on the other hand, I can’t think of a serious, low-key episode that’s ever stood out, especially compared to some of the wilder examples of the show. It’s been six years, why would I want to watch a laugh-free comedy episode when we’ve already seen Cathrine O’Hara trapped in a nightmarish courthouse and a disturbing glance at a domestic abuser collide with a face cleaving serial killer? Short answer – we don’t. Yet we still keep coming back round to them, don’t we?

Person in a blood-stained white shirt screaming with one hand raised against a wooden background

Despite the easy chemistry of Rudner and Lewis, Garris can’t quite squeeze Groundhog Day into 20 minutes, or a genuine laugh from the entire episode. Worse yet, this entry kind of chips the paint of the other two episodes that shared this year’s premier trifecta – which is extra annoying considering how awesome they both were. In comparison, “Whirlpool” just circles the drain.

We Have Issues logo with two red stars out of five and the text "Too Many Issues."

Leave a Reply