We Have Issues offers audio versions of articles using Instaread. Some words may be mispronounced.
The fifth episode of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power continues the sprawling narrative across multiple corners of Middle earth and beyond with a mixture of measured progress and familiar frustrations. It advances several key threads while revealing more of the mounting threats that threaten to reshape the Second Age, yet the overall effect remains uneven, with moments of genuine atmosphere undermined by uneven pacing and dialogue that occasionally strains against the grandeur of the setting.
The Harfoot storyline returns after a brief absence, following Nori Brandyfoot and the mysterious Stranger as the migratory community presses onward. Nori continues teaching the large, disoriented figure the ways of her people, explaining the seasonal journeys that keep the Harfoots alive and the perils that await in the middle of the trek. The travel montage through open country is accompanied by a song from Poppy Proudfellow, lending a touch of folk simplicity that echoes older tales of wandering folk. Trouble arrives in a darkened forest when wolves attack the trailing group. The Stranger intervenes with a forceful blast of power that scatters the beasts, but the effort leaves his arm badly burnt. In attempting to heal himself by drawing ice from water, he inadvertently draws Nori into the magic. The ice spreads to her, and the resulting shockwave throws her clear, leaving her frightened and uncertain about the very figure she has championed.
Meanwhile, far from the caravan, three pale figures in white robes examine the crater where the Stranger first fell from the sky, suggesting that larger forces have taken an interest in his arrival. These scenes capture a sense of quiet unease and the vulnerability of the small folk, yet the Stranger’s powers remain so vaguely defined that the it feels under written.
In the Southlands the situation grows steadily darker. The human refugees, sheltered in the old watchtower of Ostirith under the guidance of Bronwyn and the elf Arondir, receive word of Adar’s offer of safety in exchange for submission. Bronwyn tries to rally the group to stand and fight as a symbol of resistance, but division quickly sets in. Waldreg, a long established figure among the villagers, argues that survival lies in accepting the new order. Roughly half the company chooses to leave with him and seek out the orc forces. When they reach Adar, Waldreg pledges loyalty, believing the pale figure to be Sauron himself. Adar corrects the misconception with quiet menace and demands a blood oath. He forces Waldreg to kill young Rowan in order to bind himself to the cause, a grim and effective illustration of the moral compromises already underway.
Back at the tower, Theo finally confides in Arondir about the broken black sword he has been carrying. Arondir examines the markings and realises the hilt functions as a key linked to ancient designs that once enslaved the Southlanders and could help transform the land into a realm of shadow. With Adar’s army now marching in force, the remaining defenders prepare for an assault they know they are unlikely to survive. The Southlands material is the most consistently tense of the episode, grounding the larger conflict in personal desperation and the frailty of ordinary people under pressure. The choice to have Waldreg commit the killing gives a real weight to thesituation, though the sheer number of orcs surrounding against the tower risks tipping the drama into spectacle before the human cost has fully settled.
Across the sea in Númenor the political and personal proceedings grow equally complicated. Queen Regent Míriel has committed to an expedition in support of Galadriel’s cause, and preparations for the fleet gather pace. Galadriel drills the new recruits with characteristic intensity, demonstrating techniques that leave the men both impressed and intimidated. Halbrand remains reluctant to claim any public role as a potential king of the Southlands, wary of the destiny others are eager to assign him. Meanwhile, Pharazôn’s son Kemen, opposed to the venture and hoping to undermine it for his father’s political advantage, sneaks aboard one of the ships with the intention of sabotaging the stores. Isildur, who has been denied a place on the expedition by his father Elendil after his earlier failures, is also hiding on the vessel.
The two confront each other, a lantern is broken, and fire spreads to the oil casks. The resulting explosion destroys the ship and damages another. Isildur pulls Kemen from the water and later lies to Elendil, presenting the disaster as an accident and claiming he merely rescued a fisherman. The deception earns him a lowly post among the horse handlers, allowing him to sail after all. In a quieter exchange, Galadriel speaks more openly to Halbrand about the long hunt for Sauron and the personal losses that drive her, including the death of her brother. The conversation softens his resistance, and he agrees to join the force. Despite warnings from the ailing Tar Palantir that only darkness awaits in Middle earth, the remaining ships depart with Míriel, Galadriel, Halbrand, Elendil and Isildur among those aboard. The Númenórean scenes look stunning and give a sense that something is happening, yet the sabotage feels slightly contrived, and the rapid shift from reluctance to resolve among several characters leaves less room for genuine internal struggle than the stakes seem to demand.
In Lindon the elven and dwarven storylines converge around questions of trust and survival. Prince Durin joins Elrond, Celebrimbor and High King Gil galad for a formal dinner that quickly turns tense. Durin probes the elves about their sudden expansion and military movements while Gil galad presses for information about unusual activity in Khazad dûm. Durin further unsettles the hosts by questioning the provenance of their dining table, claiming the stone is sacred to his people and ordinarily reserved for monuments to the dead. Gil galad offers to return it, only for Durin later to admit to Elrond that the complaint was largely invented because Disa wanted a new table. The moment provides a welcome flash of humour and shows the easy rapport between the two friends.
Afterwards Gil galad reveals the true purpose behind Elrond’s original mission. The High King explains that the great tree of Lindon is blighted, a sign that the light of the Eldar is fading. Without a remedy the elves will either diminish or be forced to leave Middle earth. According to an ancient legend, an elven warrior once battled a Balrog beside a tree that held the light of a Silmaril. The conflict drove that light into the roots of the mountain, where it became the ore known as mithril. Gil galad believes quantities of the metal could restore the elves’ strength, and he had hoped Elrond’s friendship with Durin would uncover the dwarves’ secret mining. Elrond is left with a painful choice between his oath to keep the dwarves’ confidence and the survival of his own people. He ultimately decides on honesty, confessing the full situation to Durin. The dwarf prince, though shaken, agrees to return to Khazad dûm and attempt to persuade his father the king. The Elrond and Durin relationship remains one of the series’ most appealing elements, grounded in mutual respect and dry wit. The revelation about mithril raises the stakes effectively, even if the invented legend sits somewhat uneasily alongside established lore.
Visually the episode is stunning, putting all the money on the screen. The forests, the stone halls of Lindon, the harbour of Númenor and the shadowed approaches to Ostirith are all rendered with care, and the occasional bursts of magic or large scale movement of armies carry real impact. Performances are generally solid, with the actors doing the best with what they are given. The quieter exchanges between Elrond and Durin stand out, as does the growing tension between Galadriel and Halbrand. The problem is the amount of exposition, which feels heavy handed and weighing everything down, and the constant cutting between four major storylines sometimes dilutes the storylines. Characters occasionally announce their internal states rather than allowing them to emerge through action, and certain plot developments, such as the ease with which Isildur’s deception is accepted, stretch credibility. The episode ends on a note of something is about to happen as the Númenórean ships set sail and the orcs close in on the watchtower, yet it’s taken five episodes to get there.
Partings does important connective work, drawing the scattered threads of the season closer together and clarifying several long term threats. It offers glimpses of the moral compromises and personal costs that will shape the age to come. Yet the ambition of the storytelling is not always matched by the execution. The result is an episode that advances the larger tale with competence and occasional flashes of real power, while still leaving you wishing that the creators had done more with the material. The journey through Middle earth and Númenor continues, rich in spectacle and promise, but still trying to find its way.
Where to watch The Lord Of The Rings: The Rings Of Power – Season 1, Episode 5: Partings: