
We Have Issues offers audio versions of articles using Instaread. Some words may be mispronounced.
Now that we’ve got past another year’s triple bill to kick off the latest season, it’s time for us to settle into the weekly peaks and troughs that comes with the territory of following a legendary anthology show. If we’re keeping count of the quality thus far, season 6 is holding out strong thanks to the opening two episodes mostly smothering the damp squib of the third. However, in its fouth installment, we find the latest tale from the crypt landing somewhere inbetween, which is something of a shame considering it comes with a premise ripe with possibilities.
Yes, we’re getting another gore-free episode that’s decided to treat its source material with more of that goofy, self effacing tone that I’m rapidly getting impatient with. However, within the exaggerated performances and slightly muddled twist lies something not only quite dark, but pre-empts far more famous films that use personality disorders as a hefty rug-pull.

Nelson DeMears is the type of human doormat who seems utterly incapable of being able to handle the world in general. Completely friendless and painfully nerdy in a time when being a geek was frowned upon, Nelson is also tormented in his job as a computer programmer by his opportunistic co-worker, Jack, who happily steals all his ideas, palms them off to management as his own and then still expects the hapless DeMears to action them for him. However, possibly the most unnerving thing about Nelson is that a lifetime of being trodden on means that his imaginary friend from his childhood, Eddie, is still rattling around inside his conscienceness. While Nelson is painfully meek and unsure of himself, Eddie is brash, loud and extremely forward and he tries to get his “buddy” to come out of his shell and actually meet people – or at the very least get both of them laid.
Well, it seems that Nelson may get his chance when new neighbour Jane moves in across the hall. With the two sparking something of a easy rapport right off the bat, an excitable Eddie seems to think that his boy is finally going to score, however, during a meal between the two, the imaginary friend is horrified to discover that Jane is actually a psychologist and fears that if discovered, she’d purge Eddie right out of Nelson’s head. However, after their date, it seems that Eddie’s fears seem unfounded when Jane doesn’t contact Nelson over the next few days, which allows the beleaguered computer programmer to go back to getting advice from his excitable “friend”.
But when Jane returns back into Nelson’s life after suffering a few days of illness, Eddie takes steps to ensure he gets to stick around. Digging around in Nelson’s head to bring up the memories of various bullies from the past that required the creation of Eddie in the first place, the imaginary friend has a plan to take control of Nelson’s life by taking over his entire body!

At this point in Crypt’s history, it’s really starting to feel like any episode that isn’t pushing some sort envelope when it comes to sex, violence, or some sort of freakishly gonzo premise that indulges heavily in both, is merely just filler while we await offerings that have more balls to them. This doesn’t necessarily mean that the more restrained episodes are guaranteed to feel like time wasters, but there’s a greater chance of the more modest entries slipping through the cracks when you cast your mind back to your favourite moments of the season. Filling that brief almost completely is “Operation Friendship”, an episode that’s almost totally benign compared to more extreme offerings the show routinely gives us to devour. However, as you pick your way through an episode that’s the very definition of the word “fine”, you can’t help but wonder how more spectacular it could have been.
But let’s not speculate on that just yet and instead focused on what is; and for the most part “Operation Friendship” manages to stay just on the right side of goofy. Tate Donovan plays the nerdy Nelson, who spends so much time underfoot, his middle name might as well be dogshit, and while the actor wisely chooses to avoid going full Saved By The Bell when it comes to a stereotypical geek performance, he actually manages to find a bit of nuance in this Billy-no-mates. On the other hand, ditching nuance entirely is Peter (The Frighteners) Dobson’s imaginary friend, Eddie, who is loud and obnoxious as the suits he wears and sits somewhere between Drop Dead Fred and a particularly obnoxious stand-up comic. The notion of a grown man so repressed that his sole friend is a figment of his imagination has been utilised many times now, but rather than taking the route Fight Club went on to use, this double act has more of the feel of a weird-ass sitcom.

It goes pretty much how you’d expect – in fact, at times it feels like a psychologically screwed up variant of Friends (which debuted the same year, coincidently) that plays like Joey is the deranged, immature, imaginary friend of a far more insular Chandler. But while a wedge is driven between the two by the introduction of Michelle (Coneheads) Burke’s pretty psychologist, the episode seems disinterested in taking its premise into more violent and nastier arenas. Director Roland Mesa (whose only standout feature credit is Revenge Of The Nerds III) keeps things moving and does decent character work with his cast, but as we approach the body swapping twist which sees a disgruntled Eddie “murder” his dominant personality and take over, you can’t help but think that a more adventurous creative hand could’ve turned in something way more spectacular.
OK, so maybe at this point it was a budget issue and the producers only had enough green to go round to allow 50% of the episodes to completely cut loose, but at numerous points you’ll find yourself wondering why a premise as potentially deranged as this wasn’t allowed to go full, fucking batshit. Seeing as Eddie is only imaginary, we could have gone deeper into some trippy, reality-warping territory considering he could be anything Nelson envisioned him to be. Rather than some obnoxious costume changes, Eddie could have been virtually a living cartoon character and as his murderous impulses grew and he tries to convince Nelson to murder Jane to preserve his existence, Nelson’s entire reality could have begun to come unraveled. Alas, any hope for some Nightmare On Elm Street meets The Mask type of surrealism is just too much to hope for and as a result, “Operation Friendship” teeters between looking far worse compared to the superlative “Let The Punishment Fit The Crime” and far better compared to exceeding irritating “Whirlpool”.

While a promising concept is stripped down to its most basic form, solid performances and a half decent (if predictable) twist aren’t enough to stop the fourth episode of season 6 drifting into the realms of the forgettable. Maybe this story of a wayward imaginary friend used have used a bit more imagination itself.

