
We Have Issues offers audio versions of articles using Instaread. Some words may be mispronounced.
When will filmmakers learn that embarking on yet another film about an exorcism is still an exercise in fulitilty? Yes, once again I’m going to bang on about how the entire genre has been rendered unnecessary simply by how utterly perfect William Friedkin’s The Exorcist is, and that every attempt to play in a similar sandbox usually results in a painfully inferior copy. At least when you’re ripping off Jaws you can switch the animal around to a bear or an alligator or something, but whenever we take a hard turn into exorcism-town, it’s the same old plots and the same old iconography.
But, what’s this? Could it be that none other than Anthony Hopkins had decided to throw himself into the world of latin chants and contorting victims? That’s right, with 2011’s The Rite, we find the former Hannibal Lector becoming familiar with an entirely different kind of evil as 1408’s Mikael Håfström attempts to find something new to say about the business of expelling demons.

Disillusioned with his job working at his father’s mortuary and still carrying a load of baggage from his mother’s death during his childhood, Michael Kovak hits upon the idea to break the family cycle by entering the seminary and then renouncing his vows upon completion. This way he can score himself a college degree for free and ensure he doesn’t follow his family history of only being priests or morticians. However, four years later – as he’s about to be ordained as a deacon – Michael is intending to resign, claiming a lack of faith; but after an incident that proves he still has worth, Michael is out-manuvered by a well meaning teacher and instead sent to Exorcist school.
Attending courses in Rome at the Vatican, Michael still struggles with his faith and openly challenges his teachers about the reality of demonic possession, citing untreated mental illness as a more likely cause. In an attempt to adjust the kink in his think, Michael is sent to spend some time with Welsh Jesuit exorcist, Father Lucas, a grizzled banisher of demons whose unorthodox practises make Kovac even more nervous about the whole thing. After witnessing the priest see various potential victims of demonic possession, such as a pregnant young woman and a small boy, Michael confides in Angelina, a reporter who is taking the course in order to write a story about the Vatican’s growing need for exorcists. But the longer he spends with Lucas, the more disillusioned he continues to get.
However, when one of Lucas’ exorcisms has a tragic end, the side effects impact the older priest’s faith just as much as his young protege. The result of this is that the evil force that’s been at work finds a new home to nestle that proves to be the worst place imaginable. Can Michael find his faith and purge the corruption before the damage proves to be all-consuming?

The Rite is the latest of a clutch of modern exorcism movies that claim to be based on true events and thus treats the everything depicted within with a quiet reverence. All that is well and good, but once again, I have to point out that Friedkin did it far better decades earlier, and this slow-but-slick attempt to ride on its religious coat tails only provides yet another pretender to the throne that falls way short. The main issue here is that Håfström has been given the promising subject of a Vatican run school for exorcists, but somehow chooses to make it one of the most boring things ever. Yes, I realise that the plot is (once again) the fluctuating faith of a younger priest, so exorcist school isn’t going to work on him as much – but it’s still weird that we’re introduced to such a thing, only to immediately turn away from it once it could get interesting.
To make matters even more dour, Colin O’Donoghue’s lead is something of a mopey sort, constantly wrestling with his family’s legacy, his own faith and a distinct lack of direction despite having something of an aptitude for the work (working in a mortuary certainly weans out the squeamish). However, while there are ways to handle this on film that are dynamic and engrossing, O’Donoghue’s Michael just comes across as somewhat flat as the proceedings around him aims for brooding but just nail dreary instead. Håfström also keeps things moving pretty slow, presumably thinking that taking a more thoughtful, melancholy approach will aid the “true life” coda at the end. But rather than achieving the rank of a classy horror flick, The Rite is ridiculously devoid of scares as it’s efforts to be deliver insidious dread prove to be woefully ineffective.

However, there is one thing that salvages The Rite from it’s unfrightening scares and non-existant pace, and that’s the opportunity to watch Anthony Hopkins get to don religious garb and scream things at pasty-faced young adults. Is it art? No, not really, but if any role allows an actor to go big in a biblical sense, it’s that of a veteran exorcist who has been there, done that and bought the t-shirt. However, there’s an extra bonus in store as we don’t only get to watch Hopkins put those Welsh lungs to good use as a priest, but we also get to see him possessed as well. Considering that the former Lector has always had a mischievous streak in him, watching him gibber, curse and hiss such blasphemy is tremendous fun (his utterance of “titties” is particularly memorable for all the wrong reasons). However, watching him use some Hannibal-esque leering and different accents may be fun for those who like a bit of crazed overacting, it regrettably doesn’t actually make the film better overall and only proves to be random high points in a mostly dull film.
Quite why filmmakers can’t seem to fathom that The Exorcist will always have a stranglehold on the genre is one of the great conundrums of horror. Yes, newer generations won’t have the reverence for the 1973 classic than veterans, but on the other hand, the majority of the films that have followed in its wake aren’t particularly good when taken on their own merits either. Maybe Håfström was putting more of his possessed eggs in the “based on a true story” basket in the hope that it would chill viewers to the bone. But aside from Hopkins’ ranting, there’s nothing really here to grab you by the lapels and shake some chills into you that other, better movies haven’t already done. Even the raspy voices and twisting limbs are all feeling incredibly passé at this point and not even the power of Christ can compel us.

Yet another exorcism movie tries and fails to give us faith in a rapidly depleted genre and while Anthony Hopkins manages to wake us all up with some textbook ravings, there’s isn’t really anything here to shake up an overly familiar experience. I’m afraid it seems that this movie just doesn’t have the rite stuff…

